Does consciousness exist outside the brain reddit

Does consciousness exist outside the brain reddit. , physics, chemistry, and If you would apply the same line of reasoning, a rock would not exist outside the consciousness of something. But what about other alternatives? The notion that the brain acts as a reducing valve for consciousness was supported by the likes of Henri Bergson and Aldous Huxley, and could offer That's a really interesting point that you bring up as it's really the case that when you ask the question of why something is, you're asking for what reason it exists. ’ Modern neuroscientific approaches suggest consciousness and matter are inextricably interlinked. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Even without ears, we can measure sound. This new machine has many advantages: It is immune to decay, and perhaps it will allow you to live forever. Biologically a cow has cow consciousness and humans have human consciousness. true. Jul 1, 2012 · The hypothesis that the brain creates consciousness, however, has vastly more evidence for it than the hypothesis that consciousness creates the brain. This does not automatically include the practice of awareness or practice of being conscious. Only we have access to the mysterious essence that The fundamental issue of consciousness is that we don’t even know if consciousness does reside in the brain matter, because we don’t know if consciousness is the kind of thing that can be found. Yes it’s created by YOUR brain (mind actually). Planets, stars stand out of the emptiness of space. Further, most examples of 'out of body' experiences that scientists care to study are found to be consistent with natural, known phenomena bound to the mechanics of the brain. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Neither are my hair follicles. The human brain undergoes recursive or reentrant behavior of an unimaginably higher order of complexity than in the video system 19. Objects exist. Hence, in Fenwick’s view, the brain does not create or produce consciousness; rather, it filters it. Consciousness is the subjective experience of the most abstract components of human homeostasis, those behaviors which exist not on the level of directly responding to the change in the environment, but rather changes within the response mechanism itself to adapt to potential future circumstances. First just demonstrate it does exist (or at least tell me how you may be able to show that), and then we can have this conversation. There are certainly examples of people who are “unconscious” in the medical sense of not being alert (e. The body exists within the field of consciousness. Although for sure, all evidence points to that, and it definitely seems the most logical conclusion, the problem is that we’re limited to our own senses, and what we can see, observe and record, which is not necessarily the entire picture. This is of course a possible theory that can be proposed as an alternative to the conventional narrative. Any movement in z cannot be seen because in a 2d frame it doesn’t exist. In other words, the “mind” is a field that exists around the brain; it picks up information from outside the brain and communicates it to the brain in an extremely fast process. mind/body problem). Language creates consciousness. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS Does consciousness exist outside the brain? It implies that consciousness is a purely-physical phenomenon, and therefore it should, theoretically, be possible (though not necessarily practical) to simulate it. However, I once heard that there was a Christian (I forgot the name, and the exact wording) who came with the counterargument that even though that might be true, things exist because everything exists within God's consciousness. If free will exists, that would favor survival for consciousness to funnel into one and block out all the "noise" which exists even in a sober brain But if free will does NOT exist it seems to favor the idea it is a byproduct and therefore may be something shared by incredibly simple forms/collections of matter This might seem like a pessimistic or sobering or depressing thought, until you realize the only possible alternative is that our consciousness does not exist at all, the way the particles/substance/brain that causes our consciousness exists, which is the thing we mean by "exist". Where exactly is memory stored "outside of the brain"? Consciousness is emergent. Consciousness is an emergent phenomenon of a complex, large group of interconnected, interacting neurons. Well, I think it depends on the definition of consciousness. Bridging neural activity and my feeling of love needs much more than a brain, it needs a body, and environment, clothes on my body (or lack of). see: Solipsism) - and yet no one can refute its existence. Alternatively, we propose that consciousness may not originate in the brain, although some aspects of human perception of consciousness may be dependent on the brain. So while we can scientifically show that some functions reside within the brain, we counterintuitively cannot yet conclude that we have found the No scientist knows why or how consciousness exists. But the attachment to the concept of consciousness is what makes it seem so "mysterious" and hard to explain (i. ” Consciousness is the presence of subjective experience. “There is no empirically established explanatory framework for understanding how consciousness can exist independently and outside of the brain. We also suggest that awareness also extends beyond the brain. Before you ask me to prove "ought from is", it is incumbent upon you to show there is an "ought". The brain has been deteriorating for years, how does it come back. If those blades of grass were light waves, we would see each individual blade of grass as a different "hue," with shorter blades being closer to red, medium being closer to green, and longer ones being closer to violet. Rather, he and others are trying to find better ways to save the brain and avoid horrific “disorders of consciousness” like Terri Schiavo, the Florida woman who entered a permanent vegetative state after her brain was starved of oxygen after a cardiac arrest. So either it does originate in the brain in ways science has not confirmed just yet, or everything is just an illusion. It literally cannot describe anything that exists outside of its frame - it will only ever see more more material whatever you look for. Only you can experience your emotions. No consciousness, no perception of having a body at all. I don’t need proof leprechauns aren’t real to deduce that it’s so unlikely from the absence of evidence as to be pointless to think about. Olga Danylenko Jun 26, 2019 · In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. But the wondrous experience of consciousness itself seems to require a brain to give rise to it and a brain-based mind to perceive it. This is consciousness. Sep 11, 2020 · The solipsism problem, also called the problem of other minds, lurks at the heart of science, philosophy, religion, the arts and the human condition Explaining the phenomenology of consciousness via brain activity seems conceptually incompatible. My thoughts on this: if consciousness could exist outside of a brain then it wouldn't have to be bound to memory (because memory is bound to the brain), but since it is (we can not remember the time before we were born), I assume that the consciousness can not exist outside of a brain. This might seem like a pessimistic or sobering or depressing thought, until you realize the only possible alternative is that our consciousness does not exist at all, the way the particles/substance/brain that causes our consciousness exists, which is the thing we mean by "exist". You: No consciousness is coming from [insert some claim about how consciousness in some way exists or originates outside the brain]. If the mind is something the brain does, then no brain would have to mean no mind. Therefore, the fact that the brain itself continues to exist does not imply that one's "thread of consciousness" is identical to its predecessor from yesterday. Posted by u/EddieVicRattlehead - No votes and 45 comments Problem is, those who thinks that consciousness is created by brain are physicalists, and they believe that the mind dies with the brain, no possible way to open their minds to the possibility of rebirth. So, no, I didn’t miss the point at all. Consciousness does not exist without or outside of a brain. Personally, my two cents is that consciousness is not likely to be a specific object, like a box, or even a complicated object like a computer. I have seen some people suggest that consciousness could exist outside of the brain and that sparked my curiosity. Exactly the same here: you want me to show how some abstract notion of consciousness exists? OK. It's produced by the brain, but it's not dependent on it to exist. Consequently before you are born you do not even exist, your personality, tastes and memories (in other words "you")are yet to be developed. Everything points to consciousness being a byproduct of our brains. The consciousness did not deteriorate at all. As in death. The brain produces consciousness but consciousness, whatever that is, exists in some alternate Me: The brain produces consciousness the way computer hardware runs computer software. My best guess is that consciousness is due to some fascinating feature of the brain. If a conscious brain would freeze in the sense of every atom suddenly coming to a complete standstill in relation to every other atom in the brain, and then after some time unfreeze the brain would not be able to tell that it would have been in a frozen state from internal information. Jun 30, 2023 · GWT imagines consciousness as a theater: The brain is populated by a crowd of local information streams, but only what gets broadcast to the whole crowd — put onstage — becomes conscious Sep 15, 2022 · Evidence from “split-brain” patients — people who have the two halves of their brain surgically separated to prevent severe epilepsy — suggests that each half of the brain develops a separate sphere of consciousness, at least under some circumstances. Everything you experience is a result of physical processes in the brain, but these experiences have no effect on physical processes. New theories, such as panpsychism, the idea that consciousness exists throughout the physical universe, are on the rise. , physics, chemistry, and Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Noam Chomsky agrees with this explaination. 100% of all demonstrated Consciousness that we know of in the universe, has all originated from a material brain of some sort. He insists he isn’t after proof of the existence of an afterlife, or a supernatural hereafter. What I wonder, is, how does this happen. Jun 26, 2019 · In fact, Fenwick believes that consciousness actually exists independently and outside of the brain as an inherent property of the universe itself like dark matter and dark energy or Jan 14, 2020 · In our standard view of things, consciousness exists only in the brains of highly evolved organisms, and hence it exists only in a tiny part of the universe and only in very recent history. unless Sure, the brain processes information, but it does so in a completely different t manner than a computer does, so referring to things like the brain's hardware, software, and OS is just incorrect at all but the most trivial of levels. In philosophy, “conscious” is not usually equated with “alert. The 2d frame is modern materialism. But what is the point in being strapped into a machine when you can't change anything. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS Does consciousness exist outside the brain- Dec 15, 2021 · The materialist assumption that consciousness is produced by the brain is on the decline. I don’t think consciousness really matters as far as ASI is concerned, but the universe is computational, our brain exists inside the universe and is more or less a machine like any other, if random mutations on the plains of Africa can give rise to self awareness I see no reason to assume the process cannot be repeated (and much more efficiently mind you). I imagine consciousness to be a pattern of attenuated electrical connections and configured state ‘cells’ that together function as the brain and consciousness. it cannot be observed from the outside, so if they copied your brain, atom for atom, and you died and your clone replaced you, it would make no difference whatsoever. Dec 8, 2022 · We assume that consciousness does not exist in the absence of a brain or a central nervous system. In the case of the color red, it is the phenomenon of a brain interpreting the wavelength that a particular photon has. We understand this not completely but well enough to know we're right. Me: Prove it. 86 votes, 160 comments. Consciousness is your subjective experience. But what evidence or behavior can we observe to support this claim about the relative experience of human beings and plants? Consider the types of behavior we usually attribute to conscious life, such as reacting to physical harm or caring for others. . Something can only stand out if there is always something standing in that is the background. An intuitive definition of mine would be being aware of everything that's outside of your own mind and thus acknowledging your mind as an entity, for it can be separated from other objects. Exist in Latin: ex (out) + sistere (to stand). You: I can't. Dec 7, 2021 · I can replace your brain with a machine that is its equal in every way, so that from the outside, nobody could tell the difference. Or does it extend beyond the brain? The question of how consciousness and matter interrelate has been characterised by the philosopher David Chalmers as the ‘hard problem. For instance, if we think of the mind as something like an activity of the brain (and this is a very common view nowadays), then it would be possible for a brain to exist without a mind (it can "idle") but the mind couldn't exist without the brain. 16 One half of the brain tends to control speech and the right side of the body, while Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Consciousness requires a brain but the brain can be artificial. No brain = no consciousness. Life might as well be a movie. I believe the conciseness is not stored in the brain, but is received by it. A book I'm reading supports the claim that consciousness is nothingness by saying that if you look inside the brain of a person thinking about a mountain, you will not see a mountain but just a bunch of grey brain matter. My toe tissues are not conscious. Consciousness does not exist “out there. Jun 26, 2019 · In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. The total absence of evidence that it does is enough to prove the affirmative. In fact, Fenwick believes that consciousness actually exists independently and outside of the brain as an inherent property of the universe itself like dark matter and dark energy or gravity. This does not automatically include the… Does this not show that memory and records of the 3D are indeed kept outside of the brain? Not by itself. Brain is physical aspect of mind on the 3D plane. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS Does consciousness exist outside the brain? Jul 3, 2024 · If consciousness and behavior could come apart in other possible universes, then we need to explain not only why they come together in the human brain but also why they come together in a rational Psychology Today: Health, Help, Happiness + Find a Therapist The other option is that consciousness exists in another "dimension" which our brains tap into. Even without eyes, we can measure light. Members Online Sep 1, 2017 · If it's true that one can be conscious of life outside the body while in a coma with no brain function, then it leaves the question of where our consciousness is located unresolved. A dead brain has no self, like a broken computer has no operating system. This may not be a startling revelation, but what I mean to point out is that what you are doing when asking why something exists is asking for the purpose it serves on a relatively larger scale (relative to the thing its I think Sam takes the reasonable position that consciousness is almost certainly affiliated with the brain due to the plethora of neurocorrelates that can be measured objectively and linked to subjective experiences, however he wouldn't rule out the possibility that consciousness does not originate in the brain. A thinking agent does not actually "think". The mind exists. But does this mean the cosmos has a consciousness of its own? Jun 26, 2019 · In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. You could probably argue that consciousness emerges from the brain/body interface as Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. it is not a tangible thing, and the only reason you think it exists is because you exist. My answer to your question is no because if we make a sufficiently complex sensory network for an AI, I believe the AI could be conscious but then that would simply be a brain. For Jun 25, 2024 · Research has found the universe is remarkably similar in structure to the human brain. It's just that hard of a problem Oct 31, 2018 · Gerald Edelman proposed that “phenomenal experience itself is entailed by appropriate reentrant intracortical activity” (Edelman and Gally, 2013). " Neuroscience shows that our consciousness, intelligence and memory does not/cannot exist without the brain and when you die your brain dies with you. They claim laughable things like I'm "presupposing my own conclusion" by defining consciousness as what the brain does. Jun 3, 2021 · Our recent paper argues that consciousness involves no separate independent psychological process distinct from the brain itself, just as there’s no additional function to digestion that Jul 3, 2024 · If consciousness and behavior could come apart in other possible universes, then we need to explain not only why they come together in the human brain but also why they come together in a In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. From a lay perspective, the fact of consciousness (here meaning awareness) is so self-evident that the only question that may arise is why anyone would consider consciousness to be mysterious in the first place, akin to asking a fish, “What is water?” Dec 19, 2018 · It then “transmits wave information into the brain tissue, that … is instrumental in high-speed conscious and subconscious information processing,” Dirk wrote. ” Which is why the comparisons to light/eyes and sound/ears is terrible. Sep 6, 2022 · Neuroscience today says consciousness is generated by and localized in the brain because it emerges from brain activity. However it then requires some elaboration. Anesthesia, blunt force trauma studies, recreational drug use, simple neuroscience, the list goes on. To address your other statements, it would be more accurate to say we CANNOT reasonably or justifiably have ANY confidence that consciousness can exist without a brain, as there is ZERO evidence of a consciousness functioning without a brain outside of a person's imagination. consciousness is simply the ability to monitor your own thoughts and judgements. Likewise, my The body exists. Consciousness is an emergent property of a sufficiently complex sensory network. Literally means to stand out. And even if the consciousness does rely on a brain for awareness, and other things, does that automatically mean it will die when the brain dies? No. That stuff is all a part of the brain, and like I said, I believe the consciousness, and mind/body are separate, but connected. Outside of our brain colors would be more similar to blades of grass: all the same "thing," but all different lengths. g. Posted by u/numberonepaofag - No votes and 210 comments Long story short, there is no evidence whatsoever which suggests consciousness can exist outside the brain; in fact it goes against most of what we know in neuroscience. Sep 7, 2022 · What is consciousness? The term “consciousness” means different things to different audiences. So wrong views of physicalism (only physics stuffs exist ultimately, or everything is reducible to physics) leading to wrong views of no rebirth. I don't have any evidence. So no. , physics, chemistry, and quantum events). The study of the brain is therefore entwined with the study of Oct 18, 2023 · A recent experiment suggests the brain is not too warm or wet for consciousness to exist as a quantum wave that connects with the rest of the universe. Business, Economics, and Finance. Then there is the hybrid option. Jul 19, 2021 · They claimed that the brain’s neuronal system forms an intricate network and that the consciousness this produces should obey the rules of quantum mechanics – the theory that determines how By asking where consciousness comes from I am simply trying to point out that if the consciousness does exists beyond an inter-subjective reality then it must be the product of some physical part of the human body since the all that truly exists is matter and natural forces. e Nov 1, 2019 · We know that consciousness exists not through experiments but through our immediate awareness of our feelings and experiences. Jan 21, 2023 · Each of us knows that we are conscious, in terms of having thoughts, perceptions, and feelings, but we are unable to prove it to anyone else. No, people who say this assume consciousness is something immaterial which I have to "prove" is caused by the brain and so they think me defining it as what the brain does is "presupposing my own conclusion. Thus for anyone looking at another person's brain, there are two versions of that brain, the consciousness-composed object called a "brain" that is basically just a creation of the brain of the person is looking at another person's "brain", and the other person's brain that is not a creation of the brain of the person looking at that brain, i. Where (and how) did consciousness exist We have no means of empirical detecting the presence of consciousness, we have no means of quantifying it, no means of comparing one source of consciousness with another (we can't even agree on whether we should accept that other conscious beings exist outside our own perception. , physics, chemistry, and In a 2d frame everything can be described by x and y. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS Does consciousness exist outside the brain? We have no indication that consciousness exists outside the brain. Consciousness is. Single cells do not have consciousness. It isn't tied to a single part of the brain, it emerges from the functions of the brain as a whole. One thing that is worth considering is the epihenomenal theory of consciousness, which essentially states that the consciousness is a biproduct that arises out of the workings of the brain, but does not influence it. The soul/consciousness is not in the body. To claim that consciousness doesn't require a brain, you must first demonstrate that consciousness can or does exist without a materialistic "brain". One of the more uncomfortable ideas is that consciousness is just an accidental by-product, rather than the main purpose of the brain. e. But that implies it's not a function of the brain, and therefore it could continue after we die. Dec 19, 2019 · Parnia isn’t a religious man. Posted by u/ozonelair - 16 votes and 27 comments For discussion of the scientific study of consciousness, as well as related philosophy. Consciousness does not exist. I think you’re wrong to say it’s indisputable that consciousness is created in the brain. Crypto I don't think so, nothing would make sense, what we know implies consciousness exists outside the body, so the mind doesn't need the body But we will obviously lose our physical senses and enter a sort of dreamy state, although if you have ever looked into astral projection, you'll find its often perceived as more real than waking physical reality Because consciousness does exist as electrical neural impulses and chemical reactions in a brain. Consciousness is something like a self-experienced indivisible substance that has no physical source or a cause, and it is the very being/existing. Consciousness is not outside nor inside of the brain. . If consciousness does not reside in the brain or body, "where" is it? r/consciousness: For discussion of the scientific study of consciousness, as well as related philosophy. , in a coma) but still are “conscious” because they still have subjective experiences. ” We must define brain. This would explain how these people suddenly gain clarity. Brain, or rather mind is a decoder/processor of reality’s data. jmy jza qpks lebyp btumz qtpa upvul hzi yljrxwow jujgo